"Will Obama Inspire a New Generation of Organizers?"
Discussion list for COMM-ORG
colist at comm-org.wisc.edu
Tue Jul 8 16:10:54 CDT 2008
[ed: thanks to Aaron for the additional links. The New York Times also
had an article on Obama's organizing background yesterday.]
From: "Aaron Schutz" <schutz at uwm.edu>
FYI, with respect to Drier's article, readers might also be interested
in this blog post on Open Left
discussing Obama's organizing approach during the campaign. (It was
also reprinted at Black Agenda Report).
It is part of an ongoing series on "Core Dilemmas of Community
Organizing" (http://openleft.com/userDiary.do?personId=3384). The
attached discussion is interesting as well.
Note that this was a blog post and not a carefully researched article,
as evidenced by the updates at the end.
Associate Professor & Chair
Dept. of Ed. Policy & Comm. Studies
University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee
P.O. Box 413
Milwaukee, WI 53201
Office: (414) 229-4150
Fax: (414) 229-3700
Discussion list for COMM-ORG wrote:
> This is a COMM-ORG 'colist' message.
> All replies to this message come to COMM-ORG only.
> From: "Peter Dreier" <dreier at oxy.edu>
> For those who might be interested....My article, "Will Obama Inspire a
> New Generation of Organizers?" appears on the Dissent magazine website
> (http://dissentmagazine.org/article/?article=1215), and was posted on
> both the Huffington Post website
> and CommonDreams website
> Will Obama Inspire a New Generation of Organizers?
> By Peter Dreier
> Americans are used to voting for presidential candidates with
> backgrounds as lawyers, military officers, farmers, businessmen, and
> career politicians, but this is the first time we've been asked to vote
> for someone who has been a community organizer. Of course, Barack Obama
> has also been a lawyer, a law professor, and an elected official, but
> throughout this campaign he has frequently referred to the three years
> he spent as a community organizer in Chicago in the mid-1980s as “the
> best education I ever had.”
> This experience has influenced his presidential campaign. It may also
> tell us something about how, if elected, he'll govern. But, perhaps most
> important, there has not been a candidate since Bobby Kennedy and Eugene
> McCarthy who has inspired so many young people to become involved in
> public service and grassroots activism.
> Through his constant references to his own organizing experience, and
> his persistent praise for organizers at every campaign stop, Obama is
> helping recruit a new wave of idealistic young Americans who want to
> bring about change. According to surveys and exit polls, interest in
> politics and voter turnout among the millennial generation (18-29) has
> increased dramatically this year. But Obama isn’t just catalyzing young
> people to vote or volunteer for his campaign. Professors report that a
> growing number of college students are taking courses in community
> organizing and social activism. According to community organizing
> groups, unions and environmental groups, the number of young people
> seeking jobs as organizers has spiked in the past year in the wake of
> Obama's candidacy.
> Whether or not he wins the race for the White House, Obama, through his
> own example, has already dramatically increased the visibility of
> grassroots organizing as a career path, as well as a way to give
> ordinary people a sense of their own collective power to improve their
> lives and bring about social change.
> Obama's Organizing Experience
> In 1985, at age 23, Obama was hired by the Developing Communities
> Project, a coalition of churches on Chicago's South Side, to help
> empower residents to win improved playgrounds, after-school programs,
> job training, housing, and other concerns affecting a neighborhood hurt
> by large-scale layoffs from the nearby steel mills and neglect by banks,
> retail stores, and the local government. He knocked on doors and talked
> to people in their kitchens, living rooms, and churches about the
> problems they faced and why they needed to get involved to change things.
> As an organizer, Obama learned the skills of motivating and mobilizing
> people who had little faith in their ability to make politicians,
> corporations, and other powerful institutions accountable. Obama taught
> low-income people how to analyze power relations, gain confidence in
> their own leadership abilities, and work together.
> For example, he organized tenants in the troubled Altgelt Gardens public
> housing project to push the city to remove dangerous asbestos in their
> apartments, a campaign that he acknowledges resulted in only a partial
> victory. After Obama helped organize a large mass meeting of angry
> tenants, the city government started to test and seal asbestos in some
> apartments, but ran out of money to complete the task.
> Obama often refers to the valuable lessons he learned working "in the
> streets" of Chicago. "I've won some good fights and I've also lost some
> fights," he said in a speech during the primary season, "because good
> intentions are not enough, when not fortified with political will and
> political power." (Recently, right wing publications, radio talk shows,
> and bloggers, such as the National Review and the American Thinker, have
> sought to discredit Obama as a “radical” by linking him to ACORN and
> other community organizing groups.)
> The American Organizing Tradition
> The roots of community organizing go back to the nation's founding,
> starting with the Sons of Liberty and the Boston Tea Party. Visiting the
> U.S. in the 1830s, Frenchman Alexis de Tocqueville, author of Democracy
> in America, was impressed by the outpouring of local voluntary
> organizations that brought Americans together to solve problems, provide
> a sense of community and public purpose, and tame the
> hyper-individualism that Tocqueville considered a threat to democracy.
> Every fight for social reform since then—from the abolition movement to
> the labor movement's fight against sweatshops in the early 1900s to the
> civil rights movement of the 1960s to the environment and feminist
> movements of the past 40 years—has reflected elements of the self-help
> spirit that Tocqueville observed.
> Historians trace modern community organizing to Jane Addams, who founded
> Hull House in Chicago in the late 1800s and inspired the settlement
> house movement. These activists—upper-class philanthropists,
> middle-class reformers, and working-class radicals—organized immigrants
> to clean up sweatshops and tenement slums, improve sanitation and public
> health, and battle against child labor and crime.
> In the 1930s, another Chicagoan, Saul Alinsky, took community organizing
> to the next level. He sought to create community-based "people's
> organizations" to organize residents the way unions organized workers.
> He drew on existing groups—particularly churches, block clubs, sports
> leagues, and unions—to form the Back of the Yards Neighborhood Council
> in an effort to get the city to improve services to a working-class
> neighborhood adjacent to meatpacking factories. Alinsky's books,
> Reveille for Radicals (1945) and Rules for Radicals (1971), became the
> bible for several generations of activists. including the civil rights
> movement, the environmental movement, and many other reformers.
> There are currently at least 20,000 paid organizers in the United
> States,according to Walter Davis, executive director of the National
> Organizers Alliance. (Nobody knows for sure, since "organizer" is not an
> occupation listed by the Census Bureau). They work for unions, community
> groups, environmental organizations, women's and civil rights groups,
> tenants organizations, and school reform efforts. Unlike traditional
> social workers, organizers' orientation is not to "service" people as if
> they were clients, but to encourage people to develop their own
> abilities to mobilize others. They identify people with leadership
> potential, recruit and train them, and help them build grassroots
> organizations that can win victories that improve their communities and
> workplaces. According to organizer Ernesto Cortes, they help people turn
> their "hot" anger into "cold" anger—that is, disciplined and strategic
> The past several decades has seen an explosion of community organizing
> in every American city. There are now thousands of local groups that
> mobilize people around a wide variety of problems. With the help of
> trained organizers, neighbors have come together to pressure local
> governments to install stop signs at dangerous intersections, force
> slumlords to fix up their properties, challenge banks to end mortgage
> discrimination (redlining) and predatory lending, improve conditions in
> local parks and playgrounds, increase funding for public schools, clean
> up toxic sites, stop police harassment, and open community health
> clinics. A key tenet of community organizing is developing face to face
> contact so people forge commitments to work together around shared
> values. (The Internet has become a useful tool to connect people in
> cyberspace and then bring them together in person).
> For years, critics viewed community organizing as too fragmented and
> isolated, unable to translate local victories into a wider movement for
> social justice. During the past decade, however, community organizing
> groups forged links with labor unions, environmental organizations,
> immigrant rights groups, women's groups, and others to build a stronger
> multi-issue progressive movement. For example, the Los Angeles Alliance
> for a New Economy (LAANE) has created a powerful coalition of unions,
> environmental groups, community organizers, clergy, and immigrant rights
> groups to change business and development practices in the nation's
> second-largest city. At the national level, the Apollo Alliance – a
> coalition of unions, community groups, and environmental groups like the
> Sierra Club – is pushing for a major federal investment in "green" jobs
> and energy-efficient technologies.
> Although most community organizing groups are rooted in local
> neighborhoods, often drawing on religious congregations and block clubs,
> there are now several national organizing networks with local
> affiliates, enabling groups to address problems at the local, state, and
> national level, sometimes even simultaneously. These groups include
> ACORN, the Industrial Areas Foundation (IAF), People in Communities
> Organized (PICO), the Center for Community Change, National People's
> Action, Direct Action Research and Training (DART), and the Gamaliel
> Foundation (the network affiliated with the Developing Communities
> Project that hired Obama). These networks as well as a growing number of
> training centers for community organizers—such as the Midwest Academy in
> Chicago, the Highlander Center in Tennessee, and a few dozen
> universities that offer courses in community and labor organizing—have
> helped recruit and train thousands of people into the organizing world
> and strengthened the community organizing movement's political power.
> The "living wage" movement is an example of both coalition-building and
> linking local and national organizing campaigns. In 1994, BUILD—a
> partnership of a community organization and a local union—got Baltimore
> to enact the first local law, requiring companies that have municipal
> contracts and subsidies to pay its employees a "living wage" (a few
> dollars above the federal minimum wage). Since then, more than 200
> cities have adopted similar laws, helping lift many working families out
> of poverty. Most of their victories grew out of coalitions between
> community organizing groups, labor unions, and faith-based groups. These
> coalitions have gotten more than 20 states to raise their minimum wages
> above the federal level. These efforts helped build political momentum
> for Congress' vote last year to raise the federal minimum wage for the
> first time in a decade.
> Organizing and the Obama Campaign
> Although he didn't make community organizing a lifetime career—he left
> Chicago to attend Harvard Law School—Obama often says that his
> organizing experience has shaped his approach to politics. After law
> school, Obama returned to Chicago to practice and teach law. But in the
> mid-1990s, he also began contemplating running for office. In 1995, he
> told a Chicago newspaper, "What if a politician were to see his job as
> that of an organizer—as part teacher and part advocate, one who does not
> sell voters short but who educates them about the real choices before
> them?" Since embarking on a political career, Obama hasn't forgotten the
> lessons that he learned on the streets of Chicago.
> This is reflected in his campaign for president. Community organizers
> distinguish themselves from traditional political campaign operatives
> who approach voters as customers through direct mail, telemarketing, and
> canvassing. Most political campaigns immediately put volunteers to work
> on the "grunt" work of the campaign—making phone calls, handing out
> leaflets, or walking door to door. According to Temo Figueroa -- Obama’s
> national field director and a long-time union organizer—the Obama
> campaign has been different. “When I came on board what attracted me was
> his history as an organizer,” says Figueroa, who was working as AFSCME's
> assistant political director. “At the time I wasn’t sure I was joining
> the winning team. Most of us thought we were jumping on the little
> engine that could. We were believers. We wanted something bigger than
> ourselves. A movement.”
> Obama enlisted Marshall Ganz, a Harvard professor who is one of the
> country's leading organizing theorists and practitioners, to help train
> organizers and volunteers as a key component of his presidential
> campaign. Ganz was instrumental in shaping the volunteer training
> Many Obama campaign volunteers went through several days of intense
> training sessions called "Camp Obama." The sessions were led by Ganz and
> other experienced organizers, including Mike Kruglik, one of Obama's
> organizing mentors in Chicago. Potential field organizers were given an
> overview of the history of grassroots organizing techniques and the key
> lessons of campaigns that have succeeded and failed.
> “Organizing combines the language of the heart as well as the head,”
> Ganz says, reflecting on his experiences as an organizer with SNCC in
> the civil rights movement and as a key architect of the United
> Farmworkers’ early successes. Not surprisingly, compared with other
> political operations, Obama's campaign has embodied many of the
> characteristics of a social movement—a redemptive calling for a better
> society, coupling individual and social transformation. This is due not
> only to Obama's rhetorical style but also to his campaign’s enlistment
> of hundreds of seasoned organizers from unions, community groups,
> churches, peace, and environmental groups. They, in turn, have mobilized
> thousands of volunteers—many of them neophytes in electoral
> politics—into tightly knit, highly motivated and efficient teams. This
> summer, the campaign created an “Obama Organizing Fellows” program to
> recruit college students to become campaign staffers.
> This organizing effort has mobilized many first-time voters, including
> an unprecedented number of young people and African Americans during the
> primary season. Now that Obama is the presumed Democratic nominee, he
> faces pressure to resort to more traditional electoral strategies, but
> so far Obama and top campaign officials have continued to emphasize
> grassroots organizing. It is evident in Obama's speeches, his continued
> use of the UFW slogan, "Yes, we can/Si se puede," his emphasis on "hope"
> and "change," and the growing number of experienced organizers drawn
> into the campaign.
> Obama's stump speeches typically include references to America's
> organizing tradition. "Nothing in this country worthwhile has ever
> happened except when somebody somewhere was willing to hope," Obama
> explained. "That is how workers won the right to organize against
> violence and intimidation. That's how women won the right to vote.
> That's how young people traveled south to march and to sit in and to be
> beaten, and some went to jail and some died for freedom's cause." Change
> comes about, Obama said, by "imagining, and then fighting for, and then
> working for, what did not seem possible before."
> In town forums and living-room meetings, Obama says that "real change"
> only comes about from the "bottom up," but that as president, he can
> give voice to those organizing in their workplaces, communities, and
> congregations around a positive vision for change. "That's leadership,"
> he says.
> If elected president, will Obama's organizing background shape his
> approach to governing?
> Obama can certainly learn valuable lessons from President Franklin
> Roosevelt, who recognized that his ability to push New Deal legislation
> through Congress depended on the pressure generated by protestors and
> organizers. He once told a group of activists who sought his support for
> legislation, "You've convinced me. Now go out and make me do it."
> As depression conditions worsened, and as grassroots worker and
> community protests escalated throughout the country, Roosevelt became
> more vocal, using his bully pulpit—in speeches and radio addresses—to
> promote New Deal ideas. Labor and community organizers felt confident in
> proclaiming, "FDR wants you to join the union." With Roosevelt setting
> the tone, and with allies in Congress like Senator Robert Wagner,
> grassroots activists won legislation guaranteeing workers' right to
> organize, the minimum wage, family assistance for mothers, and the
> 40-hour week.
> After his election in 1960, President John Kennedy encouraged baby
> boomers to ask what they could do for their country. At the time, JFK
> meant joining the Peace Corps and the VISTA (Volunteers in Service to
> America) program. He could not have anticipated the wave of protest and
> activism—around civil rights, Vietnam, and later feminism and the
> environment—that animated the sixties and seventies.
> President Lyndon Johnson was initially no ally of the civil rights
> movement. However, the willingness of activists to put their bodies on
> the line against fists and fire hoses, along with their efforts to
> register voters against overwhelming opposition, pricked Americans'
> conscience. LBJ recognized that the nation's mood was changing. The
> civil rights activism transformed Johnson from a reluctant advocate to a
> powerful ally. LBJ's "Great Society" program—although criticized as too
> tame by United Auto Workers leader Walter Reuther and other
> progressives—provided some community organizing positions with
> anti-poverty agencies, job training groups, and legal services
> organizations in urban and rural areas. Many of today's veteran
> activists got their first taste of grassroots organizing in the
> anti-poverty, civil rights, and farmworker movements.
> Now comes Obama, a one-time organizer, who consistently reminds
> Americans of the importance of grassroots organizing. If he's elected
> president, he knows that he will have to find a balance between working
> inside the Beltway and encouraging Americans to organize and mobilize.
> He understands that his ability to reform health care, tackle global
> warming, and restore job security and decent wages will depend, in large
> measure, on whether he can use his bully pulpit to mobilize public
> opinion and encourage Americans to battle powerful corporate interests
> and members of Congress who resist change.
> For example, talking about the need to forge a new energy policy, Obama
> explained, "I know how hard it will be to bring about change. Exxon
> Mobil made $11 billion this past quarter. They don't want to give up
> their profits easily." Another major test will be whether he can help
> push the Employee Free Choice Act (EFCA)—a significant reform of
> America's outdated and business-oriented labor laws—through Congress
> against almost unified business opposition. If passed, EFCA will help
> trigger a new wave of organizing that will require enlisting thousands
> of young organizers into the labor movement.
> If Obama wins the White House, progressives within his inner circle will
> look for opportunities to encourage his organizing instincts to shape
> how he governs the nation, whom he appoints to key positions, and which
> policies to prioritize. Meanwhile, a new generation of volunteer
> activists and paid organizers will be looking to join President Obama's
> progressive crusade to change America. But if it appears that is veering
> too far to the political center, they will—inspired in part by Obama's
> own example, and perhaps with his covert support—mobilize to push him
> (and Congress) to live up to his progressive promise.
> Peter Dreier is professor of politics and director of the Urban &
> Environmental Policy program at Occidental College, where he teaches a
> course on community organizing. He is coauthor of The Next Los Angeles:
> The Struggle for a Livable City, Place Matters: Metropolitics for the
> 21st Century, and several other books.
> Peter Dreier
> Dr. E.P. Clapp Distinguished Professor of Politics
> Chair, Urban & Environmental Policy Program
> Occidental College
> 1600 Campus Road
> Los Angeles, CA 90041
> Phone: (323) 259-2913
> FAX: (323) 259-2734
> Website: http://employees.oxy.edu/dreier
> "The hottest places in hell are reserved for those who in times of great
> moral crises maintain their neutrality" - Dante
> Colist maillist - send messages to Colist at comm-org.wisc.edu
> To change your subscription, go to http://comm-org.wisc.edu/mailman/listinfo/colist
> All messages are archived at http://comm-org.wisc.edu/pipermail/colist/
> Please contact original message authors to request permission to forward messages.
More information about the Colist